I use Second Display with two iMacs. One of them connects over Wi‑Fi fine, the other shows “Stopped. This connection is turned off in Settings.” I never touched any switch that I remember.
Status says “Stopped. This connection is turned off in Settings”

Answer from Second Display Support ·
The setting is per display, so open Settings › Connection, choose the stopped display at the top of that tab, and turn on Allow Wi‑Fi and Ethernet for it.
It is on by default, so for this display it has been switched off, perhaps by accident. If you would rather not use the network for that display, connect it with a cable instead: a cable keeps working even with the switch off.
See Use Wi‑Fi or Ethernet and What the status messages mean.
