Apple sold three kinds of iMac in 2017: the 21.5‑inch, with or without a Retina 4K screen, the 27‑inch with Retina 5K, and the iMac Pro. Second Display makes a 2017 iMac an extra monitor for your MacBook. Open it on both Macs and the iMac displays what the MacBook sends, just like a monitor you had plugged in. A shared Ethernet network works too.

Ports, cable and picture

A 2017 iMac needs no adapter: a Thunderbolt cable with USB‑C at both ends goes straight from the iMac to a MacBook.

iMacPortCable to the MacBookWhat you get
21.5‑inch, 2017, Retina 4K includedThunderbolt 3 (USB‑C)A Thunderbolt cable, USB‑C at both ends, no adapterMedium and High are compressed with HEVC or H.264, whichever this iMac can decode. Highest is lossless and appears when the speed test clears the Thunderbolt cable
27‑inch Retina 5K, 2017Thunderbolt 3 (USB‑C)A Thunderbolt cable, USB‑C at both ends, no adapterMedium and High run at up to 60 fps in HEVC, as long as the iMac can play HEVC. Highest, the lossless level, is offered once the speed test confirms the Thunderbolt cable can carry it
iMac Pro, 2017Thunderbolt 3 (USB‑C)A Thunderbolt cable, USB‑C at both ends, no adapterWith an HEVC-capable decoder, Medium and High go up to 60 fps. For Highest, lossless, your Thunderbolt cable has to pass the speed test first

To see which one you have, choose Apple menu › About This Mac on the iMac. Apple: Identify your iMac model · Thunderbolt: which cable and which port?

The picture over the cable and over Wi‑Fi

Second Display has four quality levels: Low, Medium, High and Highest. Highest is lossless, every pixel exactly as your MacBook drew it, and you can choose it on a connection the speed test finds fast enough, such as the Thunderbolt cable. Over Wi‑Fi or Ethernet the speed test recommends the level your network keeps up with, and at Medium and High, which use HEVC, text turns sharper a moment after the picture holds still. Quality levels and the speed test · Use Wi‑Fi or Ethernet

People with a 2017 iMac 5K have run Check Smoothness over Thunderbolt, Ethernet and Wi‑Fi and shared the lag and frame rate of their 2017 iMacs.

How every other iMac compares: picture quality on an iMac as a monitor, by model and cable

Set it up

Install Second Display on both Macs. The MacBook needs macOS 14 Sonoma or later and the iMac needs macOS 12.3 or later; the 2017 iMacs and the M1, M2 and M3 MacBooks meet both. The two Macs find each other on their own, over the cable or the same network. Set up Second Display on both Macs

With a Windows 11 PC as the computer, the 2017 iMac runs the same Second Display: use it with a PC.

Questions

Why doesn’t Target Display Mode work on a 2017 iMac?

Apple made Target Display Mode only for iMacs from 2009 to mid 2014 on macOS High Sierra or earlier, and the Mac you work on has to be from 2019 or earlier with macOS Catalina or earlier. No iMac from late 2014 on has it, and no M1, M2 or M3 MacBook can use it. Second Display makes the 2017 iMac a display instead. Target Display Mode not working on Catalina

Does a 2017 iMac work with a MacBook Air over a USB‑C charging cable?

Yes. Over a USB‑C charging cable the picture is compressed over the cable’s USB link, and a Thunderbolt cable carries Highest, the lossless level. A USB‑C cable without Thunderbolt

Does a 2019 iMac work the same way?

Yes. The 21.5‑inch and 27‑inch iMacs from 2019 also have Thunderbolt 3 ports and run Second Display. Which iMacs can be a second monitor